1

Shakespeare Sonnets vs. Petrarch Sonnets:  9 Ideas for High School English

The essential skills in the first AP Literature Poetry Unit focus on poetry structure. However, students often struggle to see how poetry structure contributes to the meaning of the poem. The easiest way I have found to introduce the idea of structure in poetry is through the sonnet.  Sonnets, especially noting the difference between the Shakespeare sonnets and the Petrarch sonnets, can help to solve this problem because the structure is visible and predictable.

What is a sonnet?

In its most basic definition, a sonnet is a 14-line poem in iambic pentameter with a specific rhyme scheme.  

The three most common sonnet forms that students encounter are: 

  • Shakespeare sonnets or English sonnets
  • Petrarchan sonnets or Italian sonnets
  • Spenserian sonnets

Because sonnets follow the predictable patterns of closed form poetry, they are ideal for teaching poetic structure.  It is easy for students to practice close reading and to begin to notice shifts and their impacts.

What is a Shakespeare sonnet?

Sometimes called the English sonnet, the Shakespeare sonnet is a 14-line poem in iambic pentameter.  

The rhyme scheme is abab, cdcd, efef, gg.  

It consists of:

  • four quatrains 
  • a rhyming couplet

The final couplet is often where the poem’s major shift takes place.  It is also where the poem’s theme is revealed.

What is a Petrarch sonnet?

The Petrarachan sonnet is also a 14-line poem in iambic pentameter.  

Typical rhyme schemes include:

  • abba abba, cdc cdc 
  • abba abba cde cde.  

The poem is divided into two sections

  • an octave (8 lines) 
  • a sestet (6 lines)
9 ideas to teach the sonnets of Shakespeare and Petrarch in High School English

9 Ideas for Teaching Sonnets in High School English

The sonnet is one of my favorite ways to introduce the analysis of poetic structure.  Because it is a compressed form, it is a manageable amount of text for students to .  Here are nine engaging activities for teaching the sonnet in high school English and AP Literature.

One:  Focus on the Couplet in the Shakespeare Sonnets (Perfect Hook Lesson)

Give students just the rhyming couplet from several Shakespearean sonnets you plan to study during your Sonnet Mini Unit.  

Students can:

  • analyze diction and tone
  • identify possible themes
  • predict the conflict or argument of the poem
  • discuss what shift may have occurred before the couplet

Because Shakespearean sonnets often place the major turn in the final couplet, this activity naturally introduces students to the concept of the shift before they ever read a full sonnet.

This makes an excellent first-day hook lesson for a sonnet mini unit.

Teacher Tip: Turn this into a gallery walk by placing couplets around the room and having students rotate in groups.

Looking for ready-to-use materials? My Sonnet Mini Unit and Sonnet Notes on Form pair perfectly with this introductory activity.

Two:  Sonnets as Performance

Choose sonnets with a clear speaker, conflict, or dramatic situation. Divide students into groups and assign performance roles.

Students should:

  • determine tone and characterization
  • decide where emphasis should occur
  • identify the shift in the poem
  • perform a dramatic reading

Performance helps students hear rhythm, syntax, and emotional shifts in ways silent reading often misses.

Additionally, AP Literature Poetry Unit 1 also focuses on characterization in poetry.  This is an ideal way for students to see the development of a character through the speaker of the poem.

Three:  Sonnet “Gen Z”

One of the best ways to demonstrate understanding is through paraphrase.

Challenge students to rewrite a sonnet using Gen Z slang while maintaining:

  • the original meaning
  • 14 lines
  • the rhyme scheme
  • Bonus challenge: imitate iambic pentameter.

This activity lowers anxiety while still demanding close reading.

9 Shakespeare sonnets activities for high school English

Four:  Collaborative Annotations

One of my favorite ways to work with sonnets is to have students do collaborative annotations

There are a variety of ways to do collaborative annotations including pass a passage and having students focus on a specific annotation role. 

My favorite way to use collaborative annotations for sonnets is highlighted in this post about sonnet analysis.

Five:  Sonnets for Poem of the Week

Poem of the Week is close reading done as warm ups over the course of a week.  

The 14-line length of a sonnet makes them ideal for warm ups.  To learn more about Poem of the Week, check out this post.

Using sonnets repeatedly throughout the year also helps reinforce poetic structure long after the initial unit ends.

My Poem of the Week subscription includes recurring sonnet selections specifically designed for bell ringers and warm-ups.

Six:  Sonnet Comic Strips

Have students illustrate the sonnet using a comic strip template.

Students should:

  • visualize the speaker
  • represent the shift
  • capture tone changes visually
  • translate figurative language into images

Additionally, they can use the conventions of comic strips like speech or thought bubbles and images.

Give students the option to do this on paper or digitally.  If your students are not artists, they can use Canva which has a number of ready to use comic strip templates.

Seven:  The Sonnet Scramble

After students learn sonnet structure, cut apart a sonnet and challenge groups to reconstruct it.

Students can use:

  • rhyme scheme
  • syntax
  • punctuation
  • logical progression
  • the shift

This activity transforms poetic structure into a puzzle students genuinely enjoy solving.

Read more about a sonnet scramble in this post: “Teaching Sonnets and Disrupting Sonnets” from Much Ado About Teaching.

Eight: Shakespeare Sonnets vs. Petrarch Sonnets

Choose two sonnets on the same theme and compare how structure shapes meaning.

One pairing I love:

  • “Sonnet to Winter” by Emily Chubbuck Judson
  • “Winter Remembered” by John Crowe Ransom

Students can compare:

  • placement of the shifts
  • emotional progression
  • imagery
  • tone
  • how the structure contributes to the theme of winter and memory

This activity transitions beautifully into comparison writing.  

Nine:  Sonnet Poetry Slam

Host a bracket-style poetry showdown featuring competing sonnets.

Possible themes:

  • Shakespeare sonnets vs. Petrarchan sonnets
  • love sonnets
  • anti-love sonnets
  • nature sonnets
  • best shift
  • most dramatic speaker

Students vote and defend choices using textual evidence.

Want to extend the activity? End with an AP Lit-style paragraph defending the “winner.”

Get your free guide on how to host a poetry slam.

Teach a sonnet mini unit

A Simple Sonnet Mini Unit for AP Literature

Teaching your students about closed form poetry like the sonnet helps your students see how structure functions in a poem.  Starting with the sonnet allows students to focus on just 14-lines of text while delving into complex texts.  

Day One

Hook Lesson: Focus on the Couplet

Day Two

Mini lecture on sonnet forms
Model annotation of a Shakespearean sonnet
Partner annotation practice

Day Three

Model annotation of a Petrarchan sonnet
Partner annotation practice

Day Four

Compare two sonnets on the theme of winter

Day Five

Collaborative annotations

Day Six

Collaborative annotation gallery walk and discussion

Day Seven

AP Literature poetry analysis writing

Why Sonnets Work So Well in AP Literature

Teaching closed-form poetry helps students understand that structure is never accidental. Sonnets provide an approachable way to teach:

  • poetic shifts
  • line of reasoning
  • structure and meaning
  • symbolism
  • syntax
  • tone

Most importantly, sonnets help students build confidence before tackling more complex poetry later in the year.

Looking for ready-to-use sonnet lesson plans, annotation activities, and AP-style writing prompts? You can find all of my sonnet resources here.

Related Reading

The Sonnet in Poetry:  Teaching Sonnet Analysis

4 Ways to Teach Poetry Analysis

Collaborative Annotations for High School English

Sonnet (Academy of American Poets—poets.org)

“Teaching Sonnets and Disrupting Sonnets” from Much Ado About Teaching

Shop this post

September is Closed Form Poetry Month with a focus on Sonnets, Villanelles and more in the Pencils and Prologues Membership (reading this after September 2025–it’s all in the P&P Library of materials).

Need Sonnets in the form of a bell ringer:  try MTE Poem of the Week subscription.  Each month, one sonnet is included.

Sonnet in Poetry Mini Unit

Sonnet Notes on Form

Sonnet Collaborative Annotation

Sonnet AP Lit Style Poetry Essay Prompt

Poem of the Week Bell Ringers:  Sonnets

more from the blog

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Jeanmarie McLaughlin at McLaughlin Teaches English

Hi, I'm Jeanmarie!

I help AP Literature and High School English teachers create engaging classrooms so that students will be prepared college and beyond.

Learn more about me and how I can help you here 

Let's Connect!